Thursday, October 18, 2012

CopyCat Rice-A-Roni

I came across this recipe this summer on pinterest and gave it a try.  It was so yummy I decided it was a real keeper.  Last night I made it again, home made Rice-A-Roni CopyCat.  

The original post was by Kate over at Cooking During Stolen Moments.  

As usual, I did a couple things differently, but you can always cruise on over and see the original instructions posted by Kate.

CopyCat Rice-A-Roni
1/4 lb box pasta-thin spaghetti, angel hair, or vermicelli pasta work great
1 c. rice
3 cubes chicken bouillon or equivalent
1/2 tsp salt
1/2 tsp pepper
1/4 tsp Italian seasoning
4 Tbs butter
2 1/2 c. water
***note-you can replace the bouillon and water by using 2 1/2 c. chicken broth***

First step, break the noodles into bit-sized pieces.  I am gonna be honest, this step can be hard...or at least messy and hard to keep clean.  I used the plate method shown by Kate and had a huge mess on my hands.  My next idea was to put the spaghetti noodles into a ziplock bag and bang on it with a rolling pin.  That was still messy because the bag got holes in it and noodle bits went flying.
Last night, I pulled out my food processor, grabbed about half of the thin spaghetti and broke it in half and threw it into the food processor.  I let the machine run for a minute or so, then checked on the progress.  Half of the noodles broke down like I was hoping, while the other half were still really long.  With the second half of pasta I broke it into thirds or fourths before placing it into the food processor.  The bits did get smaller, though I still had 2" pieces.  I guess, if you have a food processor or blender, I would recommend that route over using a plate to break the noodles into bite sized pieces, but you will still need to break some pieces by hand once you process.

So, the first time I made this recipe, I had just cooked a bag of frozen chicken in the crockpot and used the resulting broth as the water in the recipe.  It tasted OUTSTANDING!  I would say that using fresh broth would be the preferred method, but making by the recipe was still a great close second. 

First, get your liquid measured and ready to pour in.  Go ahead and mix the seasoning {chicken bouillon, salt, pepper, and Italian seasoning) in a small bowl so it is ready to throw in as well.  Just like rice-a-roni, you will melt the 4 Tbs. butter in a skillet and add the rice and pasta to the pan.  Stir on med. high heat until some of the noodles start to brown.  Pour in the liquid and seasonings, stir until mixed, then bring the whole thing up to a boil.   
Cover your pot with a lid and turn the heat down to medium-low heat, but make sure it is still simmering.  The original instructions recommend simmering for 15 minutes.  I did not find this enough time.  I think you need a good 20 minutes to keep the rice from being crunchy...Maybe even 25.  This second time of making the recipe I used more water and added 5 minutes over what I did the first time.  It was much more like the texture Rice-A-Roni should be.  I went ahead and added those changes into the recipe and instructions above.

So, if you are looking to eat a few less preservatives, need a yummy side-dish, or just have a few ingredients in your cupboard and have a family to feed, this recipe fits the bill!  Give it a try.  It might just become a favorite :0)


  1. Thanks for your tested recipe.
    I am not sure about your supermarkets, but in the mexican isle they have small bags of mini pasta. There are the short sticks just like in rice-a-roni as well as some other shapes like stars, alphabets and orzo. I can usually get a bag for less than .50. Might be worth looking for.

    1. Fabulous! Good to know. I will have to check around. Wouldn't the stars or alphabet be cute!?! I bet the kids would Love that.

      Thanks for you comment!

  2. my tip for breaking up pasta is to wrap it in a cloth napkin or tea towel, kitchen towel, etc. Then crack it while its wrapped up. keeps all the pieces together. then you can unwrap it into a bowl or right into your recipe.

    also, sometimes in the "ethnic" aisle of your super market, or if you go to an ethnic market, they have a much wider variety of noodles. they do make mini vermicellis and mini spagettis.

    1. Nancy, First, sorry for the very late response. I have not had fun recovering from my trip ;0) Second, THANK YOU for your tips! I will have to look for the vermicellis at the market. I have one here in town and will give it a try. As for the tea towel, very good idea!

      Thanks for your comments!
      The Sew*er, The Caker, The CopyCat Maker


Novelty Print Quilt Pattern

I have had a hard time finding good quilt patterns for novelty prints the past couple times I purchased them.  I made up this pattern so tha...